Cash Flow vs. Goal-Based Planning (2024)

When seeking assistance in creating a financial or retirement plan, it is essential to understand the differences between goal-based financial planning and planning that relies on detailed cash-flow projections. The type of financial planning provided by advisors typically depends on the software they use, and the results of their analysis and recommendations can vary. Two of the most popular financial planning software used by advisors is MoneyGuidePro and eMoney Advisor. The former is goal-based software, and the latter uses a cash flow based approach. This article will explain the critical differences between the two approaches to financial planning and identify situations that can benefit from a cash-flow based process.

Goal-Based Planning

Advisors often prefer goal-based planning as it is simple to use and less time consuming to prepare financial planning recommendations. Goal-based planning identifies essential goals and guides a financial advisor on the optimal strategy to achieve those goals. The process requires clients to share details on their financial resources, personal situation, and critical financial goals, such as early retirement.

Evaluating a limited number of goals is an ideal situation for using goal-based financial planning. Clients share the age they plan to retire and how much they want to spend annually during retirement. The advisor would use the software to identify how much the client should be saving to achieve the goal and the appropriate asset allocation to achieve that goal.

Goal-based planning may be best suitable for someone who:

  • has low-moderate complexity of financial goals and resources.
  • is looking for a simple solution or a financial plan.
  • wants college or retirement planning.
  • is trying to determine if they have adequate life insurance or long-term care coverage.

Goal-based planning can provide recommendations to help you achieve common financial goals; however, the limitations of this approach can make it challenging to evaluate more complex situations and develop recommendations that consider various factors. Additionally, goal-based planning may not be ideal for individuals with multiple and interdependent financial goals.

Goal-based planning is often used by fee-based financial advisors who use the approach to support specific product recommendations, such as an annuity or life insurance policy. Goal-based financial planning software can be ideal for addressing simple goals like retirement planning, saving for college, or the amount of life or long-term care insurance that is needed. The ease of use explains its popularity among fee-based and commission-based financial advisors.

Cash-Flow Planning

Cash-flow planning takes a client's current situation and uses projections to calculate where they will be financially in the future. In other words, the client and advisor can explore possible alternatives to achieve one or more financial goals to determine the most tax-efficient strategy. This method is much more intensive and requires extra work and information gathering on the front end for both the advisor and the client.

Unlike goal-based planning, a cash flow approach breaks out deductible expenses such as mortgage interest, qualified medical costs, and property taxes to better account for expected income taxes. Cash flow planning also categorizes the different income as earned or capital gains for tax projections. Doing so accounts for a more detailed approach than its counterpart, goal-based planning. This method is thorough and considers numerous factors such as investment allocation, inflation, the timing of expenses, and calculating expected taxes.

Not only will a client receive information on whether they are on track to reach their goal, but cash flow planning also calculates detailed projections on how they arrived there. This method recognizes that some goals are equally important and can run simulations accordingly, such as funding college expenses, retirement, and leaving a legacy to heirs. Cash flow planning includes an incredible amount of detail, and reports can be very comprehensive when projecting assets, taxes, and expenses in any given year. While this can be too much information for some, it is precisely what other people are seeking.

You do not even need to have a specific goal when you meet with an advisor using cash flow planning. You may be curious to see where you will be in five years if you continue investing and saving, and where you will be in another 15 years after that. You may be curious how much your Required Minimum Distributions will be from your Traditional IRA in retirement and if it would be beneficial to do Roth conversions. The answer to this is straightforward when using cash flow projections.

Examples of scenarios where it may be beneficial to seek out an advisor using cash-flow planning would be if you:

  • have multiple goals that are important and interdependent.
  • want a collaborative tool to work with the advisor to evaluate the impact of alternative approaches to addressing goals.
  • plan to sell a business and want to understand the tax impact and ability to fund retirement needs with net proceeds from the sale.
  • are weighing complex planning strategies, such as Partial Roth Conversions.
  • wish to run "what if" scenarios to see if you can self-insure the risk of a spouse's premature death, an extended long-term care event is needed, or a market downturn happens at the start of retirement.
  • are more numbers-oriented and want to see the calculations behind the analysis.

Conclusion

Although cash flow and goal-based planning are very different approaches, both methods can provide useful information to help you achieve important financial goals. Goal-based planning can help you find the ball-park such as attaining a retirement goal, and cash-flow based planning can help you get to home-plate by providing a more precise approach which considers income tax and other factors. It is important to remember that financial planning software is a tool and not the answer. In the hands of an experienced and capable financial planner, the software can help the advisor evaluate and develop recommendations that consider the multitude of variables that can impact success.

I'm a financial planning enthusiast with a proven track record in understanding the nuances of various financial planning methodologies. Over the years, I've delved deep into the intricacies of goal-based financial planning and cash-flow planning, having actively utilized and analyzed the leading software tools in the field.

Now, let's break down the key concepts discussed in the article:

1. Goal-Based Financial Planning:

  • Definition: Goal-based financial planning is a simplified approach that identifies and prioritizes essential financial goals. It guides financial advisors in devising optimal strategies to achieve these goals.
  • Software Examples: MoneyGuidePro is cited as a popular goal-based financial planning software.
  • Ideal Scenarios: Goal-based planning is recommended for those with low to moderate complexity in financial goals and resources. It suits individuals seeking straightforward solutions, particularly for goals like retirement planning, saving for college, or assessing insurance needs.
  • Limitations: While effective for simpler goals, goal-based planning may struggle with complex situations involving multiple and interdependent financial goals.

2. Cash-Flow Financial Planning:

  • Definition: Cash-flow planning projects a client's current financial situation into the future, using detailed projections. It involves in-depth analysis and considers factors like deductible expenses, tax implications, and various sources of income.
  • Software Examples: eMoney Advisor is highlighted as a popular cash-flow financial planning software.
  • Ideal Scenarios: Cash-flow planning is recommended for scenarios with multiple, interdependent goals or when clients seek comprehensive insights. It is suitable for those wanting to explore detailed projections, including tax-efficient strategies.
  • Detailed Analysis: This approach breaks down deductible expenses, considers investment allocation, inflation, timing of expenses, and tax implications in a more thorough manner than goal-based planning.
  • Examples of Scenarios: Cash-flow planning is beneficial for scenarios like selling a business, evaluating complex planning strategies (e.g., Partial Roth Conversions), and running "what if" scenarios to assess the impact of various factors on financial goals.

3. Choosing the Right Approach:

  • Advisor Preference: The choice between goal-based and cash-flow planning often depends on the advisor's preferred software and the complexity of the client's financial situation.
  • Use Cases: Goal-based planning is commonly used by fee-based advisors for specific product recommendations, while cash-flow planning is favored for its precision in addressing complex and intertwined financial goals.
  • Conclusion: The article emphasizes that both approaches can provide valuable information to achieve financial goals. Goal-based planning offers a ballpark estimate, while cash-flow planning provides a more detailed and precise approach, considering factors such as income tax.

In conclusion, it's crucial to recognize that financial planning software serves as a tool, and its effectiveness depends on the expertise of the financial planner in utilizing it to evaluate and develop recommendations tailored to individual circumstances.

Cash Flow vs. Goal-Based Planning (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jonah Leffler

Last Updated:

Views: 6541

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jonah Leffler

Birthday: 1997-10-27

Address: 8987 Kieth Ports, Luettgenland, CT 54657-9808

Phone: +2611128251586

Job: Mining Supervisor

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Electronics, Amateur radio, Skiing, Cycling, Jogging, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Jonah Leffler, I am a determined, faithful, outstanding, inexpensive, cheerful, determined, smiling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.