AC Odyssey Accuse Magistrate or Doctor - Mysterious Malady Quest (2024)

Home » Assassin's Creed Odyssey » AC Odyssey Accuse Magistrate or Doctor – Mysterious Malady Quest

Accusing the magistrate or doctor is a part of the Mysterious Malady quest in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey Legacy of the First Blade. This is a potentially really important choice you’ll make. You might accuse the wrong person. Also, this quest ends up tying to the bigger picture, so you want to make the right choice in the Mysterious Malady quest, between the doctor and the magistrate. Our AC Odyssey Accuse Magistrate or Doctor – Mysterious Malady Quest guide is going to show you who to accuse in the mission.

▼Article Continues Below ▼

AC Odyssey Accuse Magistrate or Doctor - Mysterious Malady Quest (1)

Mysterious Malady Quest in AC Odyssey Legacy of the First Blade – Who to Accuse?

In the Legacy of the First Blade Mysterious Malady quest, you’ll be trying to solve the mystery of a town that has fallen ill for no apparent reason. At the climax of the quest, you’ll have to decide who to blame for this malady. This is because it’s become apparent that it’s no ordinary sickness; there’s something much more evil afoot. Your choice is between the magistrate, who does seem pretty belligerent, and the doctor, who is more timid, but still kinda shady.

';document.getElementById("serge_5f895c6208f81a315320ec57").style.display = "block"; }

As it turns out, the guilty party is the doctor. So, the correct answer is Stop lying, Doctor. Spoiler alert (although, if you came here looking for the correct answer, the point’s kinda moot either way): our good doctor is a part of the Order of the Hunter cult branch. She’s been poisoning people, from what I can gather, only to smoke you out. The whole thing was to get to you. When you accuse her, she will admit to everything, and also call her two really, really strong bodyguards. You’re in for a tough battle against the three of them.

Once you’ve killed all three of them, make sure to confirm the cultist kill and loot the good doctor’s corpse. And, that’s about it. In case you need further help with AC Odyssey Legacy of the First Blade, you can check out some of our other guides, such as How to Start Legacy of The First Blade DLC Quest, Blacksmith Code – What to Answer, and others.

AC Odyssey Accuse Magistrate or Doctor - Mysterious Malady Quest (2024)

FAQs

AC Odyssey Accuse Magistrate or Doctor - Mysterious Malady Quest? ›

Is the Doctor or the Magistrate guilty? Sail back to Potidaia and interrupt the argument between the Magistrate, Doctor, and Natakas. Based on the hints in the letter you got from the Persian Elite, you can accuse Doctor Timosa of lying. With the game up, she'll sick some thugs on you and pull out a knife.

Who is to blame the magistrate or the doctor in Assassin's Creed Odyssey? ›

Timosa: As expected, the doctor is the one everyone blames.

What is the best cultist ending in Assassin's Creed Odyssey? ›

The best ending for this arc sees the player keeping their entirely family alive, saving their sibling Deimos from the whisperings of the evil Cult of Kosmos and sparing the lives of some of their more rambunctious family members.

Who is the mysterious woman in AC Odyssey? ›

"Athena" was the name assumed by a Korinthian woman posing as the Greek goddess Athena and was active during the Peloponnesian War in the Port of Kechries, Korinthia, Greece.

What happens when you fail a quest in Odyssey? ›

There's no sync in Odyssey, so if you fail a mission it likely means there is nothing further to progress to afterwards and it won't lock you out of experiencing anything else later on. I'd recommend to load a previous save as soon as you fail a mission if you would like to complete it though.

Is the doctor or the magistrate lying? ›

Based on the hints in the letter you got from the Persian Elite, you can accuse Doctor Timosa of lying. With the game up, she'll sick some thugs on you and pull out a knife. Kill all three, and get you'll get the Persian Elite Arm Guards, as well as the satisfaction of rooting out another covert member of the Order.

Who should I accuse in Assassin's Creed Odyssey? ›

Pausanias is the cultist.

If Lagos was convinced to leave the cult in Judge, Jury, Executioner, there should be enough evidence to accuse him and have him exiled from Sparta. End of the day, it doesn't matter to the success of the quest of if there is proof or not--Pausanias will be revealed as the cultist.

Does killing Aspasia make a difference? ›

That you've destroyed the Cult of Kosmos is a good thing but, and there's a serious but, “this imbalance comes with a price”. Killing or saving Aspasia afterwards makes no difference, your actions have spawned what will become the Templars.

Is it better to use Alexios or Kassandra? ›

However, Kassandra suits the role of a heroic character far better than Alexios. Kassandra's behavior, expressions, and overall demeanor are better suited for someone who will save the Greek world from the machinations of the cult.

How do you get the secret ending in AC Odyssey? ›

How to get the best ending in Assassin's Creed Odyssey
  1. Spare Nikolaus during Chapter Two.
  2. Promise Myrinne you will try to save Deimos from the Cult of Kosmos in Chapter Six.
  3. Convince Nikolaus to intervene with Stentor when you encounter both again during Chapter Seven.
  4. Do not kill Stentor in Chapter Seven.
Jan 12, 2021

Who can you marry in Odyssey? ›

Romanceable characters in Assassin's Creed Odyssey and where to find them:
Romanceable CharacterFirst Available During
RoxanaHydrea Island Sidequest: Foot Race
ThaletasMykonos Sidequest: The Thaletas Way
XeniaAchaia Sidequest: Priceless Treasure
ZopherasLakonia Sidequest: Not My Mother's Daughter
11 more rows
Jan 12, 2021

Who is Alexios wife? ›

Theodora Kantakouzene (wife of Alexios IV of Trebizond)
Theodora Kantakouzene
Empress consort of Trebizond
Names Theodora Kantakouzene Megale Komnene
DynastyKantakouzenos
FatherTheodore Palaiologos Kantakouzenos disputed
9 more rows

Who is Alexios lover? ›

The chemistry between her and Alexios is wholesome and plays out naturally during the events of the game. Despite Kassandra being declared as the canon character, later on, the whole romance between Neema and Alexios makes more sense and was intended as the official choice during this time.

How many endings does AC Odyssey have? ›

Assassin's Creed Odyssey offers many story choices to players that will decide what kind of ending they will get out of nine available options, which may cause players to wonder what is the best ending that they can obtain in the game.

What happens if you save the sick people in Odyssey? ›

If you let the infected villagers escape, the sickness will spread across Greece. If you miss the quest by not doing it before you leave the island, or if you choose to not free the infected, the sickness will not spread.

Who is the bad guy in Odyssey? ›

As the suitors are Odysseus's mortal antagonists, Poseidon is his divine antagonist. He despises Odysseus for blinding his son, the Cyclops Polyphemus, and constantly hampers his journey home. Ironically, Poseidon is the patron of the seafaring Phaeacians, who ultimately help to return Odysseus to Ithaca.

Was Basim really a bad guy? ›

Basim Ibn Ishaq turns out to be a bonafide bad guy in Assassin's Creed Valhalla, and yet his origin story in this game is one far more endearing and earnest.

Is Hytham a bad guy? ›

Haytham E. Kenway is the titular main antagonist of the Kenway Saga within the Assassin's Creed video game franchise. He is the Grand Master of the Colonial Templar Order, the son of Edward Kenway, and the father and arch-enemy of Ratonhnhaké:ton/Connor Kenway.

Who is the villain if you play as Alexios? ›

Deimos, born Alexios, is the main antagonist of the 2018 action role-playing video game Assassin's Creed: Odyssey. He was a member of the Cult of Kosmos, a proto-Templar organization based in Ancient Greece.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lidia Grady

Last Updated:

Views: 6738

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lidia Grady

Birthday: 1992-01-22

Address: Suite 493 356 Dale Fall, New Wanda, RI 52485

Phone: +29914464387516

Job: Customer Engineer

Hobby: Cryptography, Writing, Dowsing, Stand-up comedy, Calligraphy, Web surfing, Ghost hunting

Introduction: My name is Lidia Grady, I am a thankful, fine, glamorous, lucky, lively, pleasant, shiny person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.